Friday, August 13, 2010

Russia's Advances Expose Georgia's Vulnerabilities

By David Iberi

On August 11, 2010, Russia announced that it deployed S-300 anti-aircraft missiles on the territory of the occupied Georgian region of Abkhazia. In his statement the commander of the Russian Air Force, Alexander Zelin, said that the powerful missiles were needed to provide air defense for Abkhazia and the other occupied Georgian region, “South Ossetia.” The Russian general added that apart from the S-300s, “front and army aviation” would also be employed in both territories to strengthen the air defense potential.

Two years after the full-scale invasion of Georgia, Russia not only maintains a heavy military presence in the occupied regions but has significantly advanced its strategic capabilities, which leaves Georgia extremely vulnerable to another Russian invasion. The political process to solve Tbilisi’s outstanding security problems at Geneva shows no signs for hope, and the ceasefire agreement signed through the mediation of the European Union is not working. To make the situation even worse, Georgia lives under an effective arms embargo and outside of any functioning security framework. The United States and the West’s interests seriously suffer, as well, since Russian advances into the South Caucasus diminish the region’s potential to be a reliable security and transport corridor for the operation in Afghanistan and a valuable route for energy sources from the Caspian.

The announcement of the missile deployment came three days after Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, accompanied by Anatoly Serdyukov, his defense minister, visited Abkhazia from where the majority Georgian population had been expelled in a brutal ethnic cleansing before Russia declared it independent fifteen years later, in 2008. Tbilisi condemned both Medvedev’s visit and the S-300 deployment as “cynical” moves aimed at “destabilizing the situation” and “escalating tension in the Caucasus region,” and called on the international community “to force Russia to respect the universally recognized norms and principles of the international law and to unconditionally fulfill the commitments under the six-point [ceasefire] Agreement.”

On August 12, which marked the two-year anniversary of the ceasefire between Russia and Georgia, Tbilisi came up with yet another statement accusing Moscow of being in gross violation of all six points of the agreement. “Instead of fulfilling the commitments,” the statement read, “Russia is continuously increasing the military presence on the occupied territories of Georgia and is building the military bases in order to ensure its illegal presence on the ground (5 military bases [and], approximately, 10,000 military personnel.)” Besides, Russia does not allow the only international force on the ground – the European Union’s Monitoring Mission (EUMM) – created under the auspices of the agreement “to thoroughly fulfill its mandate and have access to Georgia’s occupied territories.”

By creating and strengthening its military capabilities in Georgia’s Abkhazia and Tskhinvali region/South Ossetia, Russia is violating not only the ceasefire agreement but the most fundamental principles of international law as well, including those adopted within the framework of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) and the Conventional Forces in Europe (CFE) treaty. Notably, Moscow suspended its participation in the CFE in late 2007, months before invading Georgia.

Russia is reorganizing its military districts as part of the military reform. It was announced on August 12 that the newly created “South” Military District will now include the former North Caucasus district, which will be reinforced with other territorial units as well as the Russian bases in the occupied Georgian regions and in Armenia. The Russian news agency Regnum, close to the Kremlin, said in its publication that the reorganized military district will be capable of “delivering a more effective counterstrike” during war, “particularly with Georgia.”

The Georgian government should double its efforts to raise international awareness about its security concerns and ask the United States and other Western countries to exert more pressure on Moscow so that the latter feels obligated to meet all requirements of the ceasefire agreement. Besides, Tbilisi should speed up its military reform aimed at strengthening its command system and, overall, making the armed forces more efficient and the reserve system truly functioning.


  1. Georgia should not waste valuable resources on boosting any military capabilities, in the long run they will not achieve anything, and plunge nation in to red. In any case , vastly superior Russian army will always outnumber, outgun and outwit Georgian forces.

    Furthermore, large Georgia forces will be just unnecessary burden on Georgian Economy. And since Georgian problems cannot be resolved militarily, I think it’s an idiotic way to rely on something that will never work.

    I strongly believe that Georgian army should be reduced by at least 70-80% and contrary to popular believe have absolutely no reserve force available, Because of the danger involving general public in to any military theatre, and risk the country to engage in to Total War.

    Instead, money should be spent on educating future “political warriors” invest in general state education and kick start real economic policies that works for county , Handouts and cheap credits soon will dry up, So Georgians should be prepared to stand on their own.

  2. I say build a big fence around Georgia, toss out the foreigners, start by shutting down the US Embassy, or move it to Abkhazia, and don't let anyone in or out, and if the US wants to have a presence for its employees to take up duel Georgian citizenship as they are here to stay for the duration. Then tell Georgia, well, you got you country and the best education that mistakes and failed American policy can teach, NOW SOLVE YOUR PROBLEMS - it is time to grow up and accept responsibility for the mess you have allowed yourself to be in by sucking up so may strings attached handouts, and trying to act as a geopolitical powerhouse when you have been nothing but a lapdog for the last 200 years to some greater power.


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.